The Mystery Behind Meat Labels: Got “American” Beef?

americanbeef_canva

Where does the beef we consume actually come from? And why does it matter? 

When we purchase beef, we may not consider everything that took place before the package hit the grocery store shelf. However, where and how cattle are raised can have a big impact on the quality of meat and the overall well-being of our planet.

The following is an excerpt from Grass-Fed Beef for a Post-Pandemic World by Lynne Pledger and Ridge Shinn. It has been adapted for the web.


Restoring a Country-of-Origin Labeling Requirement

The Biden administration has the opportunity to boost rural economies all over the nation simply by requiring that meat labels in the grocery stores tell it like it is.

Currently, the labels on packages of grass-fed beef that say “Product of the USA” do not mean that the animal was born, raised, or slaughtered in the United States. This labeling only means that the beef was handled here, that it was cut into smaller pieces or ground into hamburger or otherwise minimally processed and packaged here. In fact, “Product of the USA” on a package almost certainly means that the grass-fed beef therein did not come from the United States, even if the package is adorned with American flags. Most likely the meat was imported from Australia, Uruguay, or New Zealand.

Because deceptive labeling on packages of imported grass-fed beef leads shoppers to believe that they are buying American beef, it allows companies exporting meat from overseas to cash in on the desires of many Americans to support US companies. Currently this marketing strategy is perfectly legal, but that was not always the case. The short-lived Country of Origin Labeling requirement (COOL), which required retailers to notify customers where beef came from, went into effect in 2009 but was repealed in 2016.10

Why Does It Matter?

What difference does it make where grass-fed beef cattle were raised? Customers want to know the country of origin for at least two reasons:

  1. Many want their food dollars to support the grass-fed beef movement in the United States. Ideally, they would like to buy grass-fed beef in the region where they live, so that the money spent will benefit the local or regional rural economy, and support the farmland and farm families close to home.
  2. Increasingly, people are associating 100% grass-fed beef with methods that are good for the environment and combat climate change by storing carbon in the ground.

Some people might think, “I want grass-fed beef produced with environmentally friendly methods, regardless of where on the planet these practices are happening.” Unfortunately, imported grass-fed beef is generally not produced by regenerative grazing; therefore, buying it will not support the environmental benefits that are associated with grass-fed beef. Even if the grass-fed animals overseas are not fed grain, the conventional grazing method used (which we have described as continuous grazing) will not build topsoil, store carbon, or protect against droughts and floods.

Meanwhile, it is surprisingly inexpensive to ship beef across oceans, and therefore US grass-fed beef producers are being undercut by foreign competitors. While US grass-fed is only a small part of the grass-fed market, if the Country of Origin Labeling requirement were reenacted and customers knew where their beef was coming from, we could expect a resurgence in the domestic grass-fed beef market.

So, what is the remedy for this situation? Action at the federal level. On January 3, 2022, the Biden administration issued a release pledging to “issue new ‘Product of USA’ labeling rules so that consumers can better understand where their meat comes from.”11

We’ll see.


Notes

10. Agricultural Marketing Service, “Country of Origin Labeling (COOL),” US Department of Agriculture, https://www.ams.usda.gov/rules-regulations/cool.

11. The White House Briefing Room, “Fact Sheet: The Biden-Harris Action Plan for a Fairer, More Competitive, and More Resilient Meat and Poultry Supply Chain,” January 3, 2022, https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room /statements-releases/2022/01/03/fact-sheet-the-biden-harris-action-plan-for -a-fairer-more-competitive-and-more-resilient-meat-and-poultry-supply-chain/.


Recommended Reads

Feeding the World: Why Regenerative Grazing Is So Important

The Case for Beef

Read The Book

Grass-Fed Beef for a Post-Pandemic World

How Regenerative Grazing Can Restore Soils and Stabilize the Climate

$24.95

Recent Articles

Miyawaki Method

The Miyawaki Method: Imagining a Mini-Forest’s Potential

Want to witness the magic of the mini-forest? When you practice The Miyawaki Method, a unique approach to reforestation, you’ll see an empty lot or backyard transform into a biodiverse forest before your very eyes. The following is an excerpt from Mini-Forest Revolution by Hannah Lewis. It has been adapted for the web. Photo Credit:…

Read More
urban gardening

Urban Gardening Tips: No Space? No Problem!

Do you want to learn how to transform your balconies and windowsills into productive vegetable gardens? Try urban gardening! Choosing the right crops based on climate and light conditions, along with creating a companion planting strategy to prevent pests and attract pollinators, can help maximize food production with limited space. The following is an excerpt…

Read More
spring curry

Forager’s Spring Curry: A Wild, Seasonal Recipe

Nothing says “spring” like a fresh, foraged meal! Savor the flavors of the season with this mouth-watering spring curry recipe. The following is an excerpt from Forage, Harvest, Feast by Marie Viljoen. It has a been adapted for the web. Forager’s Spring Curry This boldly flavored spring stew evolved from a forager’s version of fridge…

Read More
testing soil

Testing Soil: Healthy Soil is Just A Test Away

Testing soil in your garden is the first step to a more bountiful harvest. It’s not as hard as you might imagine, either — simply take a small sample, get it examined, and you’ll be on your way to healthy soil and a promising harvest this season. The following is an excerpt from The Regenerative Grower’s…

Read More
plant grouping

Creating A Plant Grouping: Edible Forest Gardens

Get one step closer to the edible forest garden of your dreams by creating a plant grouping! These arrangements of plants help contribute to a healthy, thriving food forest. The following is an excerpt from The Home-Scale Forest Garden by Dani Baker. It has been adapted for the web. Planning a Plant Grouping Deciding what plants to…

Read More